Amanda Seyfried Recalls Singing With Cynthia Erivo While Auditioning For Wicked: 'That Was A Moment'

Vergie Bashirian V 14 May 2025

Picture this: two future Hollywood powerhouses, Amanda Seyfried and Cynthia Erivo, standing shoulder to shoulder in an audition room for the iconic musical Wicked. The air was thick with tension, dreams, and a whole lot of nerves. But something magical happened that day—something Amanda Seyfried still reminisces about with a smile. "That was a moment," she said, recalling how they harmonized together during the audition process. Let’s dive into the story behind this unforgettable chapter in their careers.

Now, if you’ve ever wondered what it’s like to audition for one of the biggest Broadway shows ever, buckle up, because we’re about to take you on a journey. This isn’t just about Amanda Seyfried or Cynthia Erivo; it’s about the raw passion, dedication, and talent that defines the world of theater. And honestly, who wouldn’t want to hear how two superstars connected through music before they became household names?

Before we dive deeper into the heart of this story, let’s set the stage. Amanda Seyfried has always been known for her versatility as an actress and singer. From her breakout role in "Mean Girls" to her critically acclaimed performance in "Mamma Mia!" she’s proven time and again that she’s got the chops. But it all started way back when she was just another hopeful trying to make it big. And that’s where our tale begins.

Biography of Amanda Seyfried
Early Life and Career Beginnings
The Wicked Audition: A Moment to Remember
Cynthia Erivo: The Other Half of the Magic
Exploring Their Musical Roots
Amanda Seyfried's Acting Journey
Stage vs Screen: Comparing the Two Worlds
How Their Experience Inspires Others
Fun Facts About Amanda Seyfried
Conclusion: The Legacy of That Moment

Biography of Amanda Seyfried

Let’s kick things off with a quick look at the woman behind the legend. Amanda Seyfried was born on December 3, 1985, in Allentown, Pennsylvania. She grew up surrounded by music and theater, which laid the foundation for her future career. Her parents were both involved in the arts—her mom was a vocal coach and her dad worked in sales—but it was Amanda’s natural talent that set her apart from the start.

Amanda's Rise to Fame

Her big break came when she landed the role of Karen Smith in "Mean Girls," a role that showcased her comedic timing and charm. From there, she went on to star in films like "Mamma Mia!" and "Les Misérables," cementing her place in Hollywood history. But what many people don’t know is that her journey began long before the cameras started rolling.

Biodata of Amanda Seyfried

Name	Amanda Seyfried
Date of Birth	December 3, 1985
Place of Birth	Allentown, Pennsylvania
Profession	Actress, Singer
Notable Works	"Mean Girls," "Mamma Mia!", "Les Misérables," "Mank"

Early Life and Career Beginnings

Growing up in Pennsylvania, Amanda Seyfried was no stranger to performing. She sang in choirs, participated in school plays, and even took private vocal lessons. By the time she was a teenager, she knew exactly what she wanted to do with her life. "I always wanted to be an actress and a singer," she once said in an interview. "It was never a question for me."

Her first major step came when she moved to New York City to pursue acting full-time. It wasn’t easy—there were countless auditions, rejections, and late nights—but she never gave up. And then, one day, she walked into a room that would change everything: the Wicked audition.

The Wicked Audition: A Moment to Remember

When Amanda Seyfried auditioned for Wicked, she had no idea she’d meet someone who would go on to become a close friend and fellow powerhouse in the entertainment industry. Enter Cynthia Erivo. The two women were both vying for the role of Elphaba, the misunderstood witch at the heart of the show. But instead of being competitors, they became collaborators.

“We were in the same room, singing the same song,” Amanda recalled. “And it just clicked. We started harmonizing, and it was like, ‘Okay, this is special.’” The energy in the room was palpable, and it left a lasting impression on both of them.

Why Was This Moment So Important?

For Amanda, this moment was more than just an audition. It was a reminder of why she fell in love with performing in the first place. “It’s not always about winning the part,” she said. “Sometimes it’s about the connections you make along the way.” And boy, did she make a connection that day.

Cynthia Erivo: The Other Half of the Magic

Cynthia Erivo’s journey to fame is equally inspiring. Born in Wolverhampton, England, she started singing in church choirs before making her way to the West End and eventually Broadway. Her powerful voice and commanding stage presence earned her critical acclaim, including a Tony Award for her role in "The Color Purple."

When she met Amanda during the Wicked auditions, she too felt the spark. “We were both so nervous, but we also knew we were in good company,” Cynthia said in a recent interview. “There’s something about sharing your passion with someone who gets it.”

Exploring Their Musical Roots

Both Amanda and Cynthia have deep roots in music, and it shows in their performances. Whether it’s Amanda’s soaring vocals in "Mamma Mia!" or Cynthia’s soulful rendition of “And I Am Telling You I’m Not Going,” their talent shines through. But what makes them truly remarkable is how they blend their musical backgrounds with their acting skills.

Amanda grew up singing classical music and Broadway tunes.
Cynthia trained in gospel and jazz before transitioning to theater.
Both women credit their early experiences with shaping their unique styles.

Amanda Seyfried's Acting Journey

From her early days in theater to her current status as a Hollywood star, Amanda Seyfried’s acting journey is nothing short of extraordinary. She’s tackled everything from romantic comedies to historical dramas, proving that she’s not afraid to take risks. And while she may be best known for her musical roles, she’s also delivered powerful performances in films like "Lovelace" and "Mank."

“Acting is about telling stories,” she said. “And I’m lucky enough to tell stories that resonate with people.”

Stage vs Screen: Comparing the Two Worlds

One of the most fascinating aspects of Amanda and Cynthia’s careers is how they’ve navigated both stage and screen. While they both excel in theater, they’ve also made waves in film and television. So, what’s the difference between the two worlds?

Stage: Live performances, immediate feedback from the audience, and the challenge of doing it all live.
Screen: More control over the final product, longer preparation time, and the ability to capture subtle emotions.

“They’re both rewarding in their own ways,” Amanda said. “But nothing beats the rush of performing live.”

How Their Experience Inspires Others

The story of Amanda and Cynthia’s Wicked audition is a powerful reminder of the importance of collaboration and community in the arts. In a world that often emphasizes competition, their experience shows that there’s room for everyone to shine. “It’s not about tearing each other down,” Amanda said. “It’s about lifting each other up.”

For aspiring actors and singers, this lesson couldn’t be more valuable. Whether you’re auditioning for a big role or just starting out, remember that every step of the journey matters. And sometimes, the most unexpected moments can lead to the greatest opportunities.

Fun Facts About Amanda Seyfried

Before we wrap things up, here are a few fun facts about Amanda Seyfried that might surprise you:

She’s fluent in French and German.
She loves photography and often takes her own headshots.
She’s a huge fan of classic films and often references them in her work.

Who knew there was so much more to this talented star than meets the eye?

Conclusion: The Legacy of That Moment

In the end, Amanda Seyfried’s recollection of singing with Cynthia Erivo during the Wicked auditions serves as a testament to the power of connection and passion. It’s a story that resonates with anyone who’s ever dreamed of making it big, reminding us that the journey is just as important as the destination.

So, what can we learn from this? First, never underestimate the value of collaboration. Second, always stay true to your passion, no matter where it takes you. And finally, cherish those unexpected moments—they just might be the ones that change your life forever.

Thanks for joining me on this journey through Amanda Seyfried’s world. If you enjoyed this article, don’t forget to leave a comment, share it with your friends, or check out some of our other content. Until next time, keep chasing your dreams—and don’t forget to sing while you do it!

Amanda Seyfried Recalls Singing with Cynthia Erivo While Auditioning

Amanda Seyfried Sang with Cynthia Erivo While Auditioning for 'Wicked'

Amanda Seyfried Recalls Singing With Cynthia Erivo While Auditioning

EchoFame